Skip to main content

Making Sense of Gutter Guards: Are They Worth the Investment?

Lets do some Simple Math

According to Home Depot and our Knowledge your supposed to clean your gutters 2 times a year.

If the average gutter cleaning in Michigan cost $200 and you clean them 2 times a year, That’s $400 per year.

Installing gutter protection typically cost around $1100.

After Just 3 years of having gutter screens you will already break even saving $1200 with bi-annual cleanings. Now we still suggest blowing or wiping off your gutter guards every 5 years. Although in return you save $400 per year after your first 3 years. Sounds like a great investment to me!

Introduction: Living in Michigan, where the beauty of fall foliage comes with the not-so-beautiful task of dealing with clogged gutters, you know the struggle. As the owner of a gutter business, We are always looking for ways to help our customers save money and in return help J&A Exterior grow. “Gutter protection” or “leaf guards” as some my call. Not only saving you money but making sure your stress free from your gutter system.

The Gutter Guard Landscape: A Quick Overview:

Before we dive into whether gutter guards are worth the cost, let’s familiarize ourselves with the different types available in the market. As a gutter expert, knowing your options is crucial.

  1. Aluminum Gutter Cover: We Offer it’s a Great Product
    • Great Protection from Ice Dams.
    • Offer a great flow rate
    • Very Reliable
    • Cost Friendly
Black Aluminum Gutter Guard Installed to home in Clinton Township Michigan
  1. Reverse Curve Hood Guards: Expensive No Experience Using -/10
    • These guards channel rainwater around a nose-forward design.
    • Installed to match the roof’s pitch for optimal water flow.
    • Claim to keep leaves and debris out but we have not installed due to outdated age.
  2. Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh Gutter Guards: We Supply Very Cost Manor 9/10
    • High-tech guards made from super-fine stainless steel mesh.
    • Designed to block all debris, including sand.
    • Slide under roof shingles and attach to the gutter’s lip.
    • Ideal for rainwater collection systems.
    • A gutter guard worth the investment
Are Gutter guards worth the money? J&A Exterior Leaf Defender Guard.
  1. Bottle Brush Gutter Guard: Don’t Supply Because Its not Effective 4/10
    • Simple and cost-effective.
    • Resemble large, flexible bottle brushes with stiff bristles.
    • Block most leaves and debris while allowing water flow.
    • Some small debris may blow away or decompose naturally.
    • Still has to be cleaned.
  2. Nylon Gutter Guard: Decent 5/10
    • Made of nylon.
    • Fits into the gutter without attaching to shingles.
    • Prevents winter ice dams.
    • Allows water to flow even in cold climates.
    • Not very strong.
  3. Foam Filter: Not the best in our opinion – 1/10
    • Made of porous polyurethane plastic.
    • Blocks all debris but builds mold and mildew.
    • UV protection for long-lasting durability.
  4. Rain Diverter Non-Gutter Cover: 10/10
    • Replaces conventional gutters with aluminum louvers.
    • Breaks up heavy rain into small drops.
    • Redirects water away from the house harmlessly.

Are Gutter Guards Worth the investment?

Now, let’s get to the heart of the matter. Still wondering are gutter guards worth the investment for your Michigan-based home? Well if you are not convinced yet please read a few more details

Cost and Convenience: Gutter guards can be seen as a convenience investment. Cleaning gutters, especially during the fall, is time-consuming and can even be hazardous. If you want to invest and save money and time over the long run, Consider gutter protection

Adds Property Value: In the past we have had many customers ask if its worth the money to install gutter guards if they don’t know how long they may be living in their home. We typically push installing them because while it is not a very cheap investment your property value raises. Customers have reached out thanking us because when getting their home appraised, They actually made money.

Quality Matters: Remember, not all gutter guards are created equal. Some are budget-friendly, while others come with a higher price tag. Consider the quality and effectiveness of the guard. The cheaper options might require more maintenance, while the premium ones offer long-term protection.

Final Thoughts: Are gutter guards worth the investment: In conclusion, gutter guards can be a valuable asset to your your home, especially in a place like Michigan, where leaves and debris are a constant challenge. The decision ultimately boils down to do you want to spend a little money now to save you money for the rest of your homes life also choosing the right type of gutter guard for your home depending on the gutters condition, size and climate. If you would like to check out our gutter guard options please visit Gutter Guards or contact J&A Exterior.


J&A Exterior

47216 Pamela Dr, Macomb MI, 48044

248-403-0281 – jnaguttercleaning@gmail.com

If you Enjoyed Please Share and leave your comments below!

Recent Blogs

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.